BY: ZAC CORDOVA
With RobertGriffin III’s pro day finished and the pro day of Andrew Luck looming, it has
been safe to say that Indianapolis will take Luck and Washington take Griffin
right? Well wait a second. Merrill Hoge declared on ESPN recently that he would
take RG3 in “Half a heartbeat” over Andrew Luck because he believes Griffin has
better accuracy and touch on his passes. Based on a “check chart” Griffin
bested Luck in short and deep accuracy, touch, and tied in athleticism, while
Luck only bested Griffin in decision making. The meteoric rise of Griffin has
started to cast doubt that the Colts will draft Luck, and instead will go for
the man with the invisible ceiling in Griffin. This caused me, a Redskins fan,
to consider my own check chart. I based this check chart on the countless
interviews, games, situations, and combine material I gathered on both players.
Controversy at the
top?
With RobertGriffin III’s pro day finished and the pro day of Andrew Luck looming, it has
been safe to say that Indianapolis will take Luck and Washington take Griffin
right? Well wait a second. Merrill Hoge declared on ESPN recently that he would
take RG3 in “Half a heartbeat” over Andrew Luck because he believes Griffin has
better accuracy and touch on his passes. Based on a “check chart” Griffin
bested Luck in short and deep accuracy, touch, and tied in athleticism, while
Luck only bested Griffin in decision making. The meteoric rise of Griffin has
started to cast doubt that the Colts will draft Luck, and instead will go for
the man with the invisible ceiling in Griffin. This caused me, a Redskins fan,
to consider my own check chart. I based this check chart on the countless
interviews, games, situations, and combine material I gathered on both players.
Athleticism- RG3. He is just more athletic across the board.
Not to take anything away from the surprisingly athletic Luck, but Griffin is a
borderline Olympic athlete.
Short throws- Luck. I don’t know where Merrill Hoge gathered
RG3 is better than Luck at short throws, but Luck ran almost a west coast
offense at Stanford, which is based off of slants and rollouts.
Deep throws- RG3. This is his moneymaker. He has very good
touch on his deep throws, and more importantly, tends to lead his receivers
toward the sideline shoulder. Not exactly pro style, but effective nonetheless.
Mechanics- Luck. RG3 tends to short arm the ball at times, a
la Philip Rivers. Granted Rivers is a successful NFL QB, but Lucks mechanics
are a thing of beauty.
Final verdict- Luck. He is NFL ready, and will be more
effective his first couple of years. RG3 has a higher ceiling because of his
athleticism, but he is also a bigger injury risk because he leaves the pocket
more. Luck is the better QB in my opinion, but this will be a rapidly
escalating topic in the month leading up to the draft.
Please join us on our Facebook Page and follow us on Twitter @DailyShootout
Please join us on our Facebook Page and follow us on Twitter @DailyShootout
















